The usual Roth-versus-pretax rule compares today's marginal tax rate with the expected rate in retirement. Two programs have broken that comparison. Under the repayment assistance plan (RAP) for federal student loans and the premium tax credits for marketplace health insurance, payments and subsidies move with adjusted gross income (AGI), so each pretax dollar can also lower a loan payment or raise a subsidy. With the enhanced ACA subsidies expired at the end of 2025, the 400-percent-of-poverty cliff is back. David Bernstein, a retired U.S. Treasury economist, places those working-year incentives in a lifecycle framework and follows them into retirement, where large traditional balances drive required minimum distributions, taxation of Social Security benefits, and Medicare premium surcharges.
Key Takeaways
- For households on RAP or receiving ACA premium tax credits, pretax contributions can save thousands of dollars a year. Near 400 percent of the federal poverty level, choosing Roth can make coverage unaffordable.
- The cost comes later: fewer Roth assets and less control over taxable income, Social Security taxation, and Medicare premiums in retirement.
- RMD divisors shrink with age, from 26.5 at age 73 (about 3.77 percent of the balance) to 20.2 at 80 (4.95 percent) and 16.0 at 85 (6.25 percent).
- IRMAA works as five income cliffs based on MAGI from two years earlier. For 2026 the first threshold is $109,000 for individuals and $218,000 for married couples.